Journal commentary 'gets it wrong' about supps regulation

Journal commentary 'gets it wrong' about supps regulation

NPA's Welch contends that supplement regulations are firmly in place under DSHEA—it's enforcement that needs improvement.

Statement from Natural Products Association (NPA) Senior Vice President of Scientific and Regulatory Affairs Cara Welch, Ph.D., responds to a commentary in the Archives of Internal Medicine on July 9 about the regulation of dietary supplements:

“The commentary published in the Archives of Internal Medicine gets it wrong about dietary supplement regulation and may needlessly scare people into not taking products they use to support their health. It’s been long established that supplements provide nutrients we sometimes miss in our regular diet. Before taking any supplements, the Natural Products Association advises Americans to discuss supplement usage with their healthcare provider.”

“It’s important to note that supplements are a fully regulated industry under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act. We’ve said it before and we’ll say it again. The Food and Drug Administration has all the authority it needs to regulate supplements under DSHEA. And the FDA agrees. Their officials have testified before Congress that they have all the tools they need to effectively regulate supplements.”

“The FDA regulates the safety, manufacturing and labeling of supplements, while the Federal Trade Commission has the primary duty of regulating supplement advertising. The FDA and the FTC have the authority to regulate company websites and take action against companies that step out of line. Instead of more regulations, NPA believes the supplement industry needs enforcement of existing regulations. We have time and again called on Congress to provide the resources needed to fully enforce the law.”

“The commentary relies on an old Office of Inspector General report from 2001 to produce an inappropriate estimate for the supposed number of annual adverse event reports. In fact, current AER data shows that supplements have an excellent safety record considering the volume of supplements sold annually to the tens of millions of Americans who take them. Furthermore, studies have found that supplement usage could save billions in health care costs through a lower incidence of sickness and ailments.”

“NPA does share the concern about adulterated products. These illegal products are not supplements and we support continued government efforts to crack down on those who make illegal drugs marketed as supplements. Consumers looking for facts about dietary supplements can find them on NPA’s website at”


Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.