Monitor: Coast-to-coast upheaval means brands should listen firstMonitor: Coast-to-coast upheaval means brands should listen first
A groundswell of support for Black Lives Matter and demands for change have consumers re-examining social norms, but brands need to tread lightly and authentically.
June 11, 2020
Natural Products Industry Health Monitor, June 11, 2020
A global lockdown might make weeks feel like months and months weigh like centuries, but business allows little room for ennui. As distracting as the daily inundation of the negative can be, the time to look forward is always now. In this new weekly feature, Informa Health and Nutrition sister properties provide that right-now-right-here update. Look for the Industry Health Monitor each Friday to learn the major news that is affecting the natural products market immediately and the less obvious insights that could dictate where the market may struggle or thrive in the months to come.
Consider this: The natural products industry has a poor track record for diversity in leadership
If "a house divided against itself cannot stand," as Abraham Lincoln intoned in the lead-up to the Civil War, then the United States seems ever to be perched on the edge of collapse. But something different might be happening as those divisions manifest in the most raw and jolting ways. Protests are filling the streets nationwide and yet an Ipsos/ABC News poll shows us closer to agreement than ever. In a 2014 poll, 43% of respondents called the killing of Eric Garner evidence of a broad pattern of racial injustice by police. In 2020, following the death of George Floyd, that number has risen to 74%.
And yet at the same time, there is no clear agreement on what natural products brands should be doing. Many brand owners may have strong and genuine feelings about making a statement, but how many can point to concrete steps being taken to redress inequities within their own company?
New Hope Network’s Senior Vice President of Content Carlotta Mast put the matter starkly in an IdeaXchange piece last week: "According to the Natural and Organic Industry Benchmarking Survey conducted in late 2019 by the J.E.D.I Collaborative and New Hope Network, only 2% of leadership positions within our industry companies and on company boards are occupied by African Americans. The situation isn’t much better for Latinx professionals, who hold 2% of company board positions and 6% of company leadership roles within the U.S. natural products industry.”
J.E.D.I stands for “justice, equity, diversity, inclusion” and the natural products industry should clearly see the survey as a call to action. But how that action is taken is important. Bold statements without a track record of vocal advocacy and reform can look knee-jerk at best and opportunistic at worse. Put simply, authenticity matters. In a podcast interview for Natural Products Insider, Lara Dickinson, co-founder of the J.E.D.I Collaborative, explains that not every company has a Ben & Jerry’s track record and that out-of-nowhere declarations can look insincere. "It is easy to tweet support and put a poster on your website for a day but that creates a lot of noise that may limit hearing the people who need to be heard right now, the people who have experienced trauma and deserve our empathy and our ears and for us to learn from their experience,” Dickinson says.
Indeed, the natural products industry may not be a house divided, but it would be advised to get its house in order before it makes grand commitments and statements that may be well-intentioned but not backed by action.
Know this: Consumers increasingly care about corporate character
Recent civil rights protests in response to George Floyd’s killing wrenched a visceral reaction bringing much-needed awareness to the systemic racism entrenched in our society. Part of this ripple effect has companies voicing action, while also looking inward at their own practices to turn inherent biases into anti-racist policies. Additionally, consumers are confronted with their own role in anti-racist messaging, from taking action to putting more thought into where and how they are spending their money.
Beyond marching in the streets, consumers may feel they have little ability to affect change before November’s elections, but an avenue of change immediately available to them is supporting companies manifesting social values. More consumers identify with and agree with the statements that they are “willing to pay more for products that demonstrate environmentally responsible practices” and “willing to pay more for products that demonstrate socially responsible practices.” The fact that these two values-based markers are notably higher than the 2017 benchmark could reflect the heightened awareness for humanity in response to confronting the social and economic stratifications exposed through COVID-19 and compounded by civil rights protests in response to what happened to George Floyd. Do consumers directly link socially responsible practices with that of a widespread social justice movement? It’s unclear, but the emotion of the marketplace on consumers is triggering a nation toward greater awareness for fairness, and humanity.
Do this: Words speak louder with action
The natural products industry should not need a crisis to act on social justice. And it shouldn’t watch from the sidelines now. Mast offers steps and resources on how companies can engage. Mast writes, "Through these actions, we can be allies for positive change and help construct the more just, equitable and inclusive world we all deserve."
Eric Pierce, on New Hope Network’s Next Data & Insights team, reveals the advantages of diversity in an IdeaXchange piece that calls out studied and quantified advantages to diverse leadership. In one study, companies with organizational diversity yielded 21% higher financial performance. In another, companies with diverse boards experienced a 44% hike in share price.
Hear this: Hope and mission
Urgency and action: Corinne Shindelar, president emeritus of the Independent Natural Food Retailers Association, lives not far from where George Floyd died. In an IdeaXchange piece, Shindelar sees despair, hope and a role to play for the natural products industry: “And yet everywhere I biked this morning there were signs of rebuilding. Rebuilding diverse businesses, fundraising, community dialogue, civil patrols and at almost every other block a food distribution site, because what was once a vibrant food corridor is now pretty much a food desert. If that doesn’t put the problem right in front of our faces, directly following the blows from COVID-19 to our food system, I am not sure what will.”
A special resonance: Ben & Jerry’s has never shied from taking a stand for social and environmental justice, but though the company’s "We Must Dismantle White Supremacy" call to action in the wake of George Floyd’s death was intended for an audience as broad as American society, the words could easily be marching orders for the natural products industry, where white privilege is made obvious by the J.E.D.I survey cited above. The statement reads, "Unless and until white America is willing to collectively acknowledge its privilege, take responsibility for its past and the impact it has on the present, and commit to creating a future steeped in justice, the list of names that George Floyd has been added to will never end. We have to use this moment to accelerate our nation's long journey toward justice and a more perfect union."
Natural Products Industry Health Monitor Indexes
Consumer behavior indexes measure consumer behaviors through weekly surveys that are compared to a 2017 benchmark before COVID-19 emerged to see how the novel coronavirus is changing consumers. Behaviors seeking environmentally and responsibly made products, high-quality ingredients, nutrient density and transparency struggled to compete with other priorities as consumers grappled with a COVID world beginning of April. But with nearly three months of weekly tracking we see core consumer values realign with 2017 benchmark data that evaluated the same consumer behaviors.
Natural products industry engagement index tracks social and mass media engagement of the top 50 trends defining the natural products industry. The index tracks weekly keyword engagement of these top trends that are compared to a Q4 2019 weekly average benchmark before COVID-19 emerged. With three months of tracking since the outbreak of COVID-19 in the United States, engagement spikes and dips as we navigate this period of unrest but consumer engagement within these topics is growing.
Nutrition Capital Network tracks financial activity in the natural products industry. Investment activity looks to be on par with activity captured during the fourth quarter 2019 pre-COVID benchmark. Transactions taking place last week, through June 6, include significant activity in food and beverage. Hawaii-based Shaka Tea raised funds for nationwide growth, Evive secured funding for its frozen plant-based smoothie cubes, and continued investment in meat alternatives whether plant-based, insect-based or cell-based seafood.
Obvious Plant’s comedic genius deserves to be more widely known. While the brilliant and perfectly executed work (Google them!) has little to do with natural products, this particular piece unintentionally yet tangentially has something to say about both COVID-19 and civil rights matters.
Natural products consumer behavior indexes: New Hope Network NEXT Data and Insights survey of n~1,000 collected weekly since March 30, 2020, using a convenience sample directionally representative of U.S. consumers ages 18-65 weighted for age, region and gender. The 2017 survey data are based on responses of 1,000 people nationally representative of the U.S. adult population. Index tracks “top two box” responses.
Natural products industry engagement index: New Hope Network NEXT Data and Insights tracks the core 50 trends defining and innovating the natural products industry. By filtering social and mass media listening through these top trends we are able to track weekly indexes of total mentions and Net sentiment of the hot topics representative of the industry from the beginning of March 2020 compared to average weekly scores of the last three months of 2019. This allows stakeholders a view into the pulse of the industry through online conversations.
Natural products industry investment index: Nutrition Capital Network, part of Informa’s Health and Nutrition portfolio of brands, collects all investment transactions occurring in the natural products industry. Total number of investment transactions (mergers, acquisitions, financings) are tallied weekly and compared to a fourth quarter 2019 weekly average benchmark before COVID-19 emerged.
About the Author(s)
You May Also Like